What’s Next for the Padres: Trade, Extend, or Keep Luis Arraez? 

The San Diego Padres are in a tight spot as they navigate their financial landscape heading into the 2025 season. With a projected payroll that exceeds the luxury tax threshold, the front office faces tough decisions, particularly regarding Luis Arraez. After winning three consecutive batting titles, Arraez's impressive contact skills are overshadowed by his lack of power and plate discipline.

Should the Padres trade Arraez to alleviate payroll, or is extending him a more strategic move? Some argue that his unique ability to make contact—boasting a minuscule 3.4% strikeout rate—makes him invaluable, especially in a lineup that has struggled at times. Others contend that his lack of power and defensive limitations render him a liability, particularly at a projected $14.6 million arbitration salary.

What do you think? Is Arraez a player worth keeping around, or should the Padres cut their losses and look for a more versatile option? If you were in A.J. Preller's shoes, would you prioritize a trade, an extension, or simply ride out the season and make cuts elsewhere?

Additionally, how do you view the current state of the Padres? Are they in a position to contend, or is it time for a rebuild? Let’s hear your thoughts and bold predictions for the Padres' future!